Table of Contents
Note: This post contains affiliate links. Weightlift Guru may earn a commission on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Learn More Here
Summary
Walking and running are two of the most popular and accessible forms of cardiovascular exercise, each with its own set of benefits. Whether you're aiming to improve fitness, lose weight, or boost mental health, the question arises: Is walking better than running?
The answer isn’t simple. Both exercises have their advantages depending on your fitness goals, lifestyle, and physical health. Walking is a low-impact activity that’s easier on the joints and ideal for beginners or those recovering from injuries. Meanwhile, running burns more calories in less time, builds endurance faster, and offers a quick way to elevate your cardiovascular fitness.
In this article, we’ll break down the benefits and drawbacks of each, helping you decide which is the best fit for your routine—or how to balance both for maximum results.
Health Benefits of Walking vs. Running
Both walking and running are excellent forms of cardiovascular exercise, but they offer different benefits based on intensity and impact on the body. Let’s explore the unique health benefits of each:
Walking:
Low-Impact Exercise:
Walking is gentle on your joints, making it ideal for individuals dealing with conditions like arthritis, joint pain, or those recovering from injuries. It offers a way to stay active without overstressing the body, which is especially helpful for beginners or those seeking low-impact activities.
Mental Well-Being:
Walking outdoors, especially in nature, can significantly reduce stress and anxiety. It promotes mindfulness and mental relaxation, making it a great choice for those looking to de-stress while staying active.
Adaptability for All Fitness Levels:
Whether you're just starting your fitness journey or looking for an easy recovery workout, walking can be tailored to your pace and ability. It can range from a leisurely stroll to a brisk, power-walking session, offering flexibility for various fitness goals.
Running:
Higher Calorie Burn:
Running is an intense, calorie-torching workout that typically burns twice the calories of walking, depending on duration and intensity. If your goal is fat loss and time efficiency, running can deliver results more quickly.
Improves Cardiovascular Endurance:
Regular running enhances your body’s ability to use oxygen (increases VO2 max), helping to improve your stamina, endurance, and lung capacity. Over time, this makes it easier to perform physical activities for extended periods.
Strengthens Muscles and Bones:
Running is a high-impact activity that strengthens not only muscles but also bones. This is crucial for preventing bone-related conditions like osteoporosis by increasing bone density.
Both walking and running offer great health benefits, and the right choice depends on your individual goals and physical condition. Walking provides a gentler approach to cardio, while running delivers a more intense, efficient workout.
Calories Burned: Walking vs. Running
When it comes to calorie burn, both walking and running are effective, but the intensity of running gives it a significant edge. Let’s explore the differences:
Walking:
Steady Calorie Burn:
Walking burns calories at a slower rate compared to running. On average, a person walking at a brisk pace of about 3.5 mph can burn 200-300 calories per hour depending on their body weight and walking intensity.
Adaptable for Duration:
The good news is that walking is easier to sustain for longer periods. By extending your walking sessions or incorporating hills and inclines, you can increase the overall calorie burn, making it an effective fat-burning activity over time.
Good for Steady-State Fat Loss:
If you’re aiming for gradual fat loss, walking allows you to maintain an aerobic pace for longer, helping you burn fat efficiently while avoiding burnout or injury.
Running:
Quick Calorie Burn:
Running, being a high-intensity workout, burns approximately twice the calories of walking. A 160-pound person running at a pace of 5 mph can burn around 600 calories per hour, making it a time-efficient way to achieve fat loss and improve cardiovascular fitness.
Afterburn Effect:
Running also triggers an afterburn effect (excess post-exercise oxygen consumption), where your body continues to burn calories even after the workout ends, further amplifying calorie expenditure.
Best for Limited Time:
For those short on time, running is ideal as it packs a higher calorie burn in a shorter time frame. Even a 20-30 minute run can result in significant calorie loss.
Impact on Joints and Injury Risk
One of the biggest considerations when choosing between walking and running is the impact each has on your joints and the potential risk of injury. Let’s explore how both affect the body:
Walking:
Low-Impact Exercise:
Walking is much gentler on your joints compared to running. The low-impact nature of walking makes it ideal for individuals with joint issues, arthritis, or those recovering from injuries. Since both feet remain on the ground most of the time, walking reduces the repetitive pounding on knees, ankles, and hips, significantly lowering the risk of wear and tear over time.
Reduced Injury Risk:
Walking carries a lower risk of injuries like shin splints, stress fractures, or joint pain, which are more common in high-impact activities. This makes it a safer option for individuals seeking longevity in their fitness routine, especially if they’re managing chronic joint conditions.
Running:
High-Impact Activity:
Running, on the other hand, places a much greater strain on the joints due to its high-impact nature. Every stride sends a force through your legs and feet, which can lead to issues like runner’s knee, shin splints, and stress fractures over time, especially for beginners or those without proper footwear and form.
Increased Bone Density:
Despite the increased risk of joint stress, running offers long-term benefits for bone health. The impact stimulates bone growth, increasing bone density and helping to prevent conditions like osteoporosis as you age.
Proper Form is Crucial:
While running can lead to injury, proper form, the right footwear, and stretching routines can mitigate many of the risks associated with this high-impact exercise.
Mental and Emotional Benefits
Both walking and running offer tremendous mental and emotional health benefits, but they work in different ways to enhance your overall well-being. Let’s look at how each can improve your mood and mental state:
Walking:
Relaxation and Stress Relief:
Walking is often seen as a more meditative exercise. The repetitive, steady movement combined with outdoor scenery can help reduce stress and anxiety. Studies have shown that walking, particularly in nature or green spaces, can lead to lower cortisol levels (the stress hormone) and improved mental clarity.
Time for Reflection:
Walking offers a slower, gentler pace that allows you to clear your mind, reflect, or even practice mindfulness. This makes it ideal for people looking to reduce mental fatigue, or for those seeking a calming break during a busy day.
Boosts Creativity:
Walking has been linked to improved creativity and problem-solving. The rhythmic motion of walking helps free up the mind, making it easier to think through challenges or generate new ideas.
Running:
Endorphin Rush (Runner’s High):
Running, especially at higher intensities, triggers the release of endorphins, which can lead to a euphoric feeling often referred to as the "runner’s high." This mood boost can help combat anxiety, depression, and stress while promoting a sense of accomplishment.
Improves Mental Resilience:
The physical challenge of running also builds mental toughness. Pushing through a tough run teaches perseverance and grit, which can translate into improved emotional resilience in daily life.
Short-Term Mood Boost:
Because running is more intense, it offers a faster way to release built-up stress and improve your mood. Even a short 20-minute run can lift your spirits, especially on days when you feel mentally drained.
Accessibility and Convenience
When considering whether walking or running fits into your lifestyle, accessibility and convenience play a huge role. Let’s look at how each stacks up in terms of ease of access, gear requirements, and time commitment:
Walking:
No Special Equipment Needed:
One of the greatest advantages of walking is that it requires little to no special equipment. All you need is a comfortable pair of shoes, and you’re ready to go. This makes it a highly accessible form of exercise for virtually anyone, regardless of fitness level or experience.
Can Be Done Anywhere:
Walking is extremely versatile. Whether you're walking around your neighborhood, on a treadmill, or through a scenic park, walking can be done almost anywhere, anytime. It’s perfect for those who prefer a more flexible workout routine without needing access to a gym.
Time Commitment:
Walking is generally slower-paced than running, meaning it might take longer to burn the same number of calories. However, because of its low intensity, walking is sustainable for longer periods, making it easier to fit into daily routines like commuting, walking meetings, or breaks.
Running:
Requires More Stamina and Preparation:
Running requires more stamina and preparation than walking. It can be tough for beginners to sustain a run without gradually building endurance. Additionally, proper running shoes are highly recommended to prevent injuries and maximize performance, especially for frequent runners.
More Time-Efficient:
If you’re short on time, running is a more efficient way to get a workout. Because running burns more calories per minute, you can get in a solid cardio session in less time than walking. A 20-30 minute run can provide the same calorie-burning effect as a 45-60 minute walk.
Suitable for Structured Training:
Running is often preferred by people who enjoy setting structured fitness goals, such as preparing for races or improving pace and distance. It’s a great way to add variety to your routine by mixing in sprints, intervals, or long-distance runs.
When to Choose Walking Over Running (and Vice Versa)
Both walking and running have their advantages, but which one is better for you depends on your current fitness level, health goals, and lifestyle. Here’s a breakdown of when you should prioritize walking or running based on your needs:
Choose Walking If:
You’re Recovering from Injury or Have Joint Concerns:
Walking is a low-impact exercise that minimizes strain on your joints, making it ideal if you’re dealing with arthritis, joint pain, or recovering from injury.
You’re New to Fitness:
If you’re just starting your fitness journey, walking is a gentler introduction to cardiovascular exercise. It helps build endurance without the intensity or risk of overuse injuries.
You Want a Low-Impact, Relaxing Workout:
Walking offers a slower pace that can be relaxing, meditative, and easier to maintain for longer durations. It’s perfect for those looking for a calming workout that’s easy on the body.
You Need More Flexibility:
Walking requires minimal preparation, can be done anywhere, and fits easily into your daily routine. It’s ideal if you’re looking for a simple, accessible way to stay active.
Choose Running If:
You Want to Burn More Calories in Less Time:
Running is a higher-intensity workout that burns more calories in a shorter amount of time. If you’re pressed for time but want a highly effective workout, running is the way to go.
You’re Focused on Cardiovascular Fitness and Endurance:
If your goal is to improve VO2 max and build cardiovascular endurance quickly, running will deliver results faster than walking.
You’re Training for a Race or Event:
Running is the go-to exercise for preparing for races, marathons, or any event that requires endurance. It’s also great for athletes looking to improve speed and stamina.
You Enjoy a Challenge:
Running can be physically and mentally demanding, which makes it perfect for those who enjoy pushing their limits and setting measurable fitness goals.
Can You Combine Both for Maximum Results?
Instead of choosing between walking and running, you can combine both to create a well-rounded fitness routine. Blending the two offers the best of both worlds—giving you the calorie-burning intensity of running and the low-impact benefits of walking. Here’s how you can effectively combine them:
The Hybrid Approach:
Walk-Run Intervals:
A popular approach is alternating between walking and running during the same workout. For example, you can walk for 2 minutes, then run for 1 minute, repeating this cycle for 30-45 minutes. This method, known as interval training, allows you to build endurance gradually while getting the benefits of both exercises. It’s ideal for beginners looking to progress into running without overwhelming their joints or stamina.
Walking on Rest Days:
Use walking as a recovery tool between intense running sessions. Low-impact walks on your rest days can help improve circulation, promote active recovery, and reduce muscle stiffness, all while still keeping you active.
Use Walking to Build Running Endurance:
If you’re training for a long-distance race or event, walking can be an essential part of your endurance-building process. Walking longer distances at a moderate pace can improve your aerobic capacity, which directly translates to better stamina during runs.
Key Benefits of Combining Both:
Reduced Injury Risk:
Alternating between walking and running helps balance the high impact of running with the gentler motion of walking, lowering your overall risk of injury while maintaining an active lifestyle.
Improved Endurance and Fat Loss:
Mixing walking and running provides steady-state cardio benefits from walking, while the intensity of running burns calories quickly and boosts cardiovascular health.
Sustainable for All Fitness Levels:
Whether you’re just starting or already advanced, combining walking and running is an effective way to maintain consistency without burning out.
Walking vs. Running—Find What Works Best for You
In the debate of walking versus running, there isn’t a one-size-fits-all answer. Both exercises offer incredible health benefits, and the best choice depends on your individual fitness goals, physical condition, and personal preferences. Walking provides a low-impact, accessible workout that’s perfect for beginners, those with joint concerns, or anyone looking for a relaxing, meditative form of exercise. On the other hand, running is a powerful tool for burning calories, improving cardiovascular fitness, and achieving quick results in less time.
Ultimately, you don’t have to choose one over the other—combining both walking and running can create a balanced routine that helps you stay active, avoid injury, and reach your fitness goals. Whether you're using walk-run intervals or incorporating walking on recovery days, blending the two offers the best of both worlds. The key is to find a routine that keeps you motivated and consistent, so you can enjoy the long-term benefits of staying active.
Related Posts:
Walking vs. Running: Which Burns More Calories and Why? Learn about the calorie-burning potential of walking and running to support your fitness goals.
Running for Fitness: Key Benefits and Tips for Beginners: Discover how running can elevate your fitness journey, with tips for getting started.
Top Benefits of Walking: Why It’s the Perfect Low-Impact Workout: Find out why walking is one of the best exercises for your physical and mental health.